New idea for prison design seeks to rehabilitate, rather than punish - Article
My thoughts on this:
We don't need rehabilitation, we need regeneration, which only comes through the Gospel. Man may be able to change some outward behaviors, but only God can change someone's heart and give them a new nature in Christ Jesus. Besides if we don't have real punishment for crime -that is, justice- then we are just slapping victims in the face, and we are saying that we have a better way than God.
Remember, God punishes sin! He put his Son on the cross for our sin! He does not allow sin to go unpunished, and neither should we allow crime to go unpunished.
But what about mercy? Isn't God merciful? God has given us mercy we do not deserve! But this does not mean that sin is not dealt with in God's justice!
Even earthly justice is from God, as it says in Romans:
"Let every person be subject to the governing authorities. For there is no authority except from God, and those that exist have been instituted by God. Therefore whoever resists the authorities resists what God has appointed, and those who resist will incur judgment. For rulers are not a terror to good conduct, but to bad. Would you have no fear of the one who is in authority? Then do what is good, and you will receive his approval, for he is God's servant for your good. But if you do wrong, be afraid, for he does not bear the sword in vain. For he is the servant of God, an avenger who carries out God's wrath on the wrongdoer. Therefore one must be in subjection, not only to avoid God's wrath but also for the sake of conscience. For because of this you also pay taxes, for the authorities are ministers of God, attending to this very thing." (Romans 13:1-6, ESV)So, the governing authorities have authority to do what? - Punish! "He... carries out Gods wrath on the wrongdoer"!(from Verse 4, above)
Rightful, just punishment by governing authorities is from God. It is to be a "terror" (deterrent) to those who do wrong. If we do not have real, lawful punishment, by governing authorities, then we are not doing God's will as a society. Also, I think there would be no proper respect for authority in general as people may tend to do whatever they want then, without fear.
We should reject the notion of prisons for rehabilitation, and keep them for punishment. Lets not make them like hotels.
Spiraling Prison populations, is the problem to be solved in the article. But is it the result of a wrong approach to prisons? No. It is the result of spiraling crime caused by sin and the degradation of real justice in our society as we seek to eliminate God and His Laws from our public and private life. Its not because we've somehow been using a "wrong approach" to prisons (ie. punishment) which leaves us with "67% recidivism".
Actually the Spiraling Prison population is not the problem, but our failure to properly deal with crime to begin with. We don't begin with God's Law anymore. We don't call sin what it is anymore. We have to be politically correct.
As far as the programs to get people prepared to enter society, aren't we supposed to be doing that when they are children – so that maybe they won't become criminals later on? Any reasonable person can see that.
Where are the parents? Why are kids sitting down and being baby-sat by violent video games? And then why they are expected to be prepared to go out into society with even a hint of a proper mind-set? Is anyone thinking?
And public schools? - breeding grounds for immoral, godless ideas and the promotion of the idea that we are just animals that evolved with no purpose from other, lower, animals! Ideas have consequences! (Public schools are part of the problem - one of the reasons we end up with so many criminals).
The article mentions promoting “a sense of dignity and empowerment which can reduce their chances of re-offending”. So, we want to teach them this AFTER they commit a crime?
Anyone taught Biblical Truth and values from childbirth is likely to have that sense of God-given dignity as they understand that we are made in His image! You DO NOT get get that sense of dignity from thinking that we are just evolved animals! This should be taught to them since childbirth! So perhaps, God willing, instead of “re-offending”, they won't offend the first time (with reference to committing a crime).
But alas, due to our sin nature, even our best efforts will not fully curtail sinful behavior or crime. God deals with sin. Repent and believe the Gospel. That is the solution.
Punishment for crime in society is part of God's plan, and should not be modified or done away with!